
What if New Jersey had gone forward with the ambitious transit microgrid it began more than a decade ago? Would the state be better positioned today to deal with its electricity supply problems?
A new report by the non-profit Garden State Initiative (GSI) argues that canceling NJ TRANSITGRID in January 2024 cost the state more than an opportunity to strengthen its transportation system.
Support our work with a free or paid subscription.
Conceived after Superstorm Sandy in 2012, the project was among the largest and most pioneering microgrids proposed in the US at the time.
Early plans called for a generating facility of up to 140 MW near Kearny, with dedicated power lines serving portions of Amtrak’s Northeast Corridor, NJ TRANSIT’s Morris & Essex Lines and Hudson-Bergen Light Rail.
The microgrid would have kept trains running during widespread grid outages and potentially supplied electricity to the larger grid during normal operations.
The project secured nearly $410 million in competitive federal resilience funding. It also offered an interesting business opportunity for the microgrid industry. NJ TRANSIT pursued a public-private partnership under which a private company would design, build, finance, operate and maintain the infrastructure.
But the project encountered opposition over its use of natural gas, particularly given the environmental burdens already facing communities near the site. So in 2020, NJ TRANSIT began pursuing a design that relied more on renewable energy and storage.
Ultimately, NJ TRANSIT canceled the project, citing unfavorable economics revealed through competitive bidding and improvements to the regional electric grid. The agency redirected $503 million to other transportation resilience projects.
A case for revival
Report author Chris Jeter, a former NJ TRANSIT official who worked on the microgrid project for more than four years, argues that strengthening the electric grid is no substitute for having an independent source of power.
In the report, Resiliency Lost: The Energy and Leadership Costs of Canceling NJ Transit’s Grid Infrastructure, he recommends that New Jersey revive the project, but take a more incremental approach. That would mean initially serving the most critical rail corridors and expanding as energy storage technology advances and costs decline. He also calls for limited, low-emission backup generation, local air-quality monitoring and binding environmental benefits.
For the microgrid industry, the project offers a lesson in the risks of pursuing large public infrastructure contracts. Jeter argues that abandoning projects after years of courting private investment raises the perceived risk — and potentially the cost — of future projects.
The report also raises a question worth considering beyond New Jersey: Are there other unrealized microgrid investments that should be reconsidered now that the nation faces possible capacity shortages?



